- Henry Kaste 1889 - 1890
- Frank H. Wellemeyer 1890
- Henry Schwietert 1890
- Henry Schuldt 1893
- W. F. Mertz 1893
- Gottlieb Haefner 1894 - 1897
- Henry C. Hilmer 1897 - 1898
- A. M. Brenner 1898 - 1901
- Adolph Dulitz 1901 - 1904
- George H. Wessel 1904 - 1910
- Henry W. Schneider 1910 - 1913
- William J. Witter 1913 - 1916
- Arthur H. Meyer 1916 - 1921
- W. C. H. Bergmann 1921 - 1923
- Albert W. Gauger 1923